If their job is to sing on stage, they should be able to do that at least. And do it well. It's very clear cut to me, at least.
8 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
XXX dimplebottoms • 11 hours ago
yeah i know that perfectly well, i just hate it when kpop fans used it so freely just to justify that some IDOLS are talentless just cause they can't sing or dance as if those idols ain't talented in other areas, it irks me when people used the word talent so freely lol
1 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Chococta XXX • 10 hours ago
No no..talents are singing and dancing well..just that..some people really need to compare the newbie with their senior..
I guess people forgot that being idol not only sing dan dance..for me..being idol means entertaining the audience. Singing is important if they are on stage..but you need more just singing to be an entertainer.
I like your question by questioning the definition of talent. Hv great day
P.s sorry for may bad english
1 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
JENCHAU Netizen101 • 11 hours ago
seriously lets put talents aside at least they can be trained to become better singers but i think THEY LACK individuality.. it's just a group of pretty girls dancing
1 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
melramsyy JENCHAU • 11 hours ago
Lol lack individuality how??? Care to explain? Have you ever watched them before? And they just debuted ffs.
12 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
HallyuYUYA JENCHAU • 11 hours ago
lol that's the main thing going for them right now, how they're all different atleast
2 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
nobody :3 Netizen101 • an hour ago
they are talented in different areas tho...
BUT
Twice's visuals r too superior, so people just drag down on their talents..
even if they only debut for 3 days....
n d bullshit "coming from big 3" (does not apply to JYPE tho..we all can obviously see they r not powerful as the other 2 when it comes to mediaplay or promotion)
n they don't even sounded that bad as some claimed. LOL
• Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Ren Netizen101 • 3 hours ago
It was their first stage. Anyone who dont follow them can't know abt their talents. Beauty is what ppl can see right away. And it's kpop we taking abt
• Reply•Share ›
Avatar
beatriz Netizen101 • 8 hours ago
to be honest kpop is more visual than talent, if you see the groups most don´t sing so well, so maybe that´s why kpop groups will never be able to be famous in the west!
• Reply•Share ›
Avatar
0607diadem Netizen101 • 8 hours ago
i'm sure if those two other "great vocalist" sixteen contestants joined, their lineup would have been fucked up for sure. I'm pretty sure JYP hand picked the members carefully.
• Reply•Share ›
Avatar
KenToufan . Netizen101 • 10 hours ago
i am taling ab it~
• Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Fantasiana Netizen101 • 11 hours ago
This is Kpop where most people more attracted to visual than talent. Even the famous Suzy and Yoona got famous because of their visual.
• Reply•Share ›
Avatar
hass Fantasiana • 11 hours ago
at least suzy can sing but these twice girl have no singing talent the one who can sing leave jyp
8 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
HallyuYUYA hass • 10 hours ago
I love Suzy but Jihyo and Nayeon are just as good as Suzy. Suzy is no power vocal, don't be delusional.
7 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Fantasiana hass • 5 hours ago
When Suzy debuted everybody goes crazy about her visual too not her talent. Even today people only praises her beauty. Suzy's singing ability also just as good as Jihyo and Nayeon.
1 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
poop hass • 11 hours ago
Lol there are actually good singers in twice, their not the best, but wyd
1 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
wellduhh Fantasiana • 11 hours ago
Yoona's a really good dancer and Suzy can sing fairly well. Shoot, even Yoona's debut singing beat the majority of these girls. They also showed their acting chops.
4 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Fantasiana wellduhh • 5 hours ago
Momo also a good dancer and Jihyo also Nayeon sings as good as Suzy too. Chaeyoung's rap is way better and stable than SNSD rapper line.
• Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Fantasiana wellduhh • 5 hours ago
Momo is a good dancer and Jihyo's vocal more than average and way better than Yoona's voice. Chaeyoung's rap is better than any of SM female rapper line.
• Reply•Share ›
−
Avatar
Sora234 Netizen101 • 9 hours ago
The thing is if you watch Sixteen, Jihyo was always the much better vocalist than Minyoung, which is ironic, considering Minyoung is the one who was media played as a main vocalist. Here is an MR Removed version:
I learned the dance and its actually pretty difficult trying to sing and dance it at the same time. They just debuted too. I remember when EXO first debuted I couldn't hear a word, but here we are, and EXO's Love Me Right stages were super stable. Jihyo is a better singer than Minyoung, she just hasn't realized it yet. Once she gets used to being the main vocalist, the songs will become more vocally challenging. Look at SNSD. Yoona, Hyoyeon, Yuri, and Sooyoung used to not be good at all. If you listen to Lion Heart, all nine of them sing well now. With time, Twice will improve.
• Reply•Share ›
Avatar
JENCHAU • 11 hours ago
seriously having great visuals =/= having star potential
gotta admit they have REALLY great visuals but their talent IS REALLY WEAK in my opinion, the performance is REALLY REALLY FLAT
225 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Kanye West JENCHAU • 11 hours ago
their talent is just the same as other groups in kpop. not bad but not that good. Why are people suddenly complaining now? It's always been that way. I try not to rag on groups too much especially if they're rookies.
175 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Ela Brown Kanye West • 10 hours ago
people on NB act like they suddenly cared about great singing abilities only in kpop and like being a good dancer was not a talent. i bet many of those who trashed twice stan groups where there's at least one visual.
129 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
thaieo Ela Brown • 10 hours ago
I respect people's opinion about Twice, no one's obliged to think they're good or whatever but it's honestly funny how some of them have these really mediocre idols as dps while they claim it's a shame that looks are more important than talent, I'm like ???
56 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
kimmyungsoo thaieo • 9 hours ago
Yeah and you can even found some comments about certain idols being all good in singing than twice members when the idols are lack at the singing
9 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Enlight Ela Brown • 10 hours ago
hey, dont compare other groups visual to twice. its just not fair. lol
1 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Jenni vy Kanye West • 10 hours ago
Thank you!! The girls aren't even bad, people are just jumping on the hate bandwagon. The girls have some skills and their singing can really improve in the future.
54 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
gerbil Jenni vy • 5 hours ago
oh shut up. not everyone has to like them.
• Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Jenni vy gerbil • 4 hours ago
And I'm not forcing you to bash them either. Why you being pressed.
1 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
Vladislava Kanye West • 10 hours ago
yeah totally. Take 9muses for instance. They don't have strong vocalists too but folks here (me included lol) clearly don't have a problem with that and hype them up like there's no tomorrow. At this point I legit start suspecting that all the critisizm that they get here is because koreans seem to actually like them lmao
9 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
doublebubbletrouble Kanye West • 11 hours ago
You've got to be kidding me. It's definitely not the same when you line them up against groups like Spica, Mamamoo or BEG lol.
41 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
HallyuYUYA doublebubbletrouble • 11 hours ago
out of the 50 new groups that exist today their are only that handful, your statement does nothing to counter his point. The majority has been like this.
And who's to say all of them are untalented?
37 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
RinB doublebubbletrouble • 9 hours ago
Not every group is meant to be a Spica or Mamamoo. And vocal ability does not always equal success in pop music... Spica is a perfect example of that.
14 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
QQBBQ doublebubbletrouble • 11 hours ago
None of those groups can dance. And for all your "talent" none of those groups has even 1 distinctive talent. They are good singers but they blend together. A group of basically vocal trainers isn't going to be a success in any pop genre around the world. I mean the most famous out of BEG is Ga In and she's the "least" talented vocally. She is famous more for her look and her variety.
Twice has Jihyo and Nayeon which is enough for any Kpop act. Being homely and being able to project loudly =/= talent and that's why Minyoung and Jiwon were cut. Being pretty doesn't necessarily mean you are not talented.
I'm not arguing for or against Twice, simply stating the obvious that they're not less talented than any other Kpop group. There's probably not a half dozen girls in Kpop who can 1) sing, 2) dance 3)have performance presence 4) look pretty like Nayeon. She's basically like Jessica, except better at dancing with an actual personality other than being a princess
53 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
HallyuYUYA QQBBQ • 10 hours ago
as a Twice fan as well I'm going have to ask you to pull out that Jessica example, she was actually one of SNSD's better singers. Sure as hell preferred her over Tiffany. :)
20 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
wellduhh QQBBQ • 10 hours ago
Jessica's a really good dancer, just a lazy one
22 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
#REDLIGHT QQBBQ • 10 hours ago
Jessica is muuuch better singer tho and she's queen so comparing her with Nayeon was bad idea.
23 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
sam ÷418 QQBBQ • 10 hours ago
Jessica has a personality apart from being a princess though.
6 • Reply•Share ›
Avatar
ms101 doublebubbletrouble • 10 hours ago
i agree, Twice definitely ca