In matters of justification one simply cannot dispense with the issue of intentionality, and by extension agency, in the way premise does. Intentionality is a conceptual precondition of normative evaluation. Ignoring it would render the notion of responsibility superfluous. At its extreme, dispensing with the issue of intentionality as related to responsibility would permit one to make such arguments as, “Because everyone must eventually die someday, one is justified in taking another’s life.” Unfortunately, this is exactly what is indicated with the assumption that: if contexts always influence your behaviour in predictable ways, this implies that you are always be- ing nudged. Said differently, such a conceptual move blurs a crucial distinction at the heart of normative justification as to the notion of responsibility.